Scent marketing statistics travel badly. A modelled best-case estimate becomes "scent lifts sales 23%" in a sales deck, a single small study becomes "research shows," and a null result disappears. This page lists the primary sources we rely on, what each one measured, and the number it actually supports. Every entry links to the journal record or an open-access copy; we do not cite papers we have not read.
1. The meta-analysis: Roschk & Hosseinpour (2020)
Journal of Marketing, 84(1). doi:10.1177/0022242919881137 (open access).
- Integrates 671 effects from ambient-scent experiments.
- Pleasant ambient scent "on average produces a substantial increase in the level of customer responses (3%–15%)."
- Spending: modelled increases of 3% for an average condition and 23% for a most favorable condition. These are model outputs, not observed sales. Quote them that way.
- Effects are "more cognitive than affective": scent moves evaluation and judgment more than mood.
- Effects are larger when the scent is congruent with the setting, reads as one clear idea (unidimensional), is familiar, and is used in a service setting rather than goods retail.
- Perceived concentration has nonlinear effects: intensity has an optimum.
2. The field experiment: Girard, Lichters, Sarstedt & Biswas (2019)
Journal of Service Research, 22(4). doi:10.1177/1094670519842333 (open access).
- German regional railway; jasmine, melon and violet-leaf fragrance delivered through the trains' existing air-conditioning, which is HVAC delivery.
- Study 1: 204 passengers, scented vs. unscented coaches. Service quality 4.24 vs 3.77, service experience 3.82 vs 3.19, service value 3.69 vs 3.05; short-term effects small to medium.
- Study 2: four months, nine waves, 35 commuters completing all waves. Long-term effects larger; two weeks after the scent was removed, experience and value ratings had not significantly declined.
- Only 27% of passengers consciously recognized the scent.
- Caveat: the samples are modest and the setting is a train. Describe it as a four-month field experiment on a working railway, never as large-scale.
3. The systematic review: Giacalone, Pierański & Borusiak (2021)
Applied Sciences, 11(13), 6195. doi:10.3390/app11136195 (open access).
- 20 studies met the bar: real retail environment, ambient scent, behavioral variables, experimental data.
- Most report positive effects on emotional states; evidence for behavioral effects is inconsistent.
- Neither the S-O-R nor the thematic-congruency framework is consistently supported, so congruency is supported but not settled.
- Methodological gap: scent composition rarely reported, intensity "generally not reported," and only 3 of 20 studies specified the diffuser or its placement, which are exactly the variables that decide whether a program works.
4. The null: McGrath, Aronow & Shotwell (2016)
SpringerPlus. PMC4899340 (open access).
- Randomized controlled trial, 31 days, chocolate scent in a Canadian bookstore and café.
- No statistically significant effect on total, book, café, or bulk sales.
- Caveat the authors themselves raise: the store was 800 square feet with about 21 customers a day, so statistical power was low. It is an honest null, not proof of no effect.
5. Simplicity and processing fluency: Herrmann, Zidansek, Sprott & Spangenberg (2013)
Journal of Retailing, 89(1), 30–43 (no stable open link; cited from the article).
- Home-decoration store, 18 days, 402 purchasing customers.
- Average spend: simple orange scent 56.83 CHF; complex basil-orange-green-tea blend 43.11 CHF; no scent 45.96 CHF. The complex blend performed no better than no scent.
- Three lab studies attribute the mechanism to processing fluency. "Simple" means the scent reads as one idea, not that it has few ingredients.
- Caveat: only two scents were used across all four studies.
6. Intensity: Leenders, Smidts & El Haji (2016)
Journal of Retailing and Consumer Services. doi:10.1016/j.jretconser.2016.05.007.
- Major supermarket, melon scent at three intensity levels; outcomes included actual time in store and store-level sales.
- Only the high intensity moved evaluations, time in store, and sales; lower levels did not.
- In the author manuscript, about 302 shoppers took part. At the noticeable (70%) intensity, store takings rose 13.8% and time in the store rose 27%. At the fainter (50%) intensity, nothing changed significantly.
7. Individual variation: Liu, Awada, Becerik-Gerber, Lucas & Roll (2023)
Journal of Environmental Psychology, 91, 102135.
- 48 young adults, bergamot via electric diffuser, simulated office task under time pressure.
- Both sexes self-reported less stress; physiology diverged, with men showing increased heart rate and rating the office less pleasant than control.
- Limits: one scent, one intensity, student-age sample, simulated task.
8. Brand memory: Morrin & Ratneshwar (2003)
Journal of Marketing Research. Rutgers record.
- Two lab experiments. People who viewed brands in a scented room recalled and recognized them better 24 hours later.
- The mechanism was attention: people paid more attention to the brands while the scent was present.
- Caveat: a lab setting, and the outcome is brand memory, not repeat business.
9. Product scent and memory: Krishna, Lwin & Morrin (2010)
Journal of Consumer Research. ScienceDaily summary.
- Scent built into a product improved memory for the product's details for at least two weeks.
- Distinctive scents faded from memory less than common ones.
- Caveat: ambient scent was weaker than product scent for memory of one specific item.
10. Casino coin-in: Hancock (2009)
UNLV master's thesis. UNLV repository.
- Four fragrances rotated across 253 slot machines for 20 days at one casino.
- Refreshing and soothing blends significantly increased coin-in.
- Caveat: an unpublished thesis at a single property; the abstract reports no effect size.
How to read all of this together
Scent reliably changes how a space is evaluated. It sometimes changes behavior. The size of the effect depends on fit, intensity, and delivery, and the published literature mostly fails to report those variables. That is the evidence-based reason the test that matters is the one run in your own building, which is why every Aroma Impressions program starts with a seven-day on-site trial. For the plain-language version of this page, see what scent marketing is and why it matters; for the social-behavior evidence from hotel and bar settings, see does scent make people more social?
Numbers we do not use
These figures circulate in scent marketing materials, and most name no author, year or journal. Here is what each one traces to, as far as we could find, and why we leave it out.
- "45% more spent on slot machines." Hirsch 1995 in Psychology & Marketing: one weekend at one Las Vegas Hilton slot area, where one of two scents showed the rise and the other showed no change. It has never been replicated (Casino.org). For the casino study we do cite, see section 10; for how music, fit and intensity shape a gaming floor, see scent and sound on the gaming floor.
- "40% more dwell time" in casinos. Cited as "an additional casino study" with no source. Untraceable.
- "Typing errors fell 54% with lemon." Attributed in trade press to a Japanese fragrance maker, with no year, method or journal (Personnel Today). Untraceable to any published study.
- "84% more likely to buy" (Nike). An unpublished 1990 preliminary report; academic reviewers say the figure rests on about three people (MPRA paper).
- "We remember 35% of what we smell and 5% of what we see." Attributed to Rockefeller University, but no Rockefeller paper says it. Untraceable.
- "75% of emotions are generated by smell." Traced only to neuromarketing books and vendor pages. Untraceable.
- "100 times more likely to remember a smell." No source anywhere.
- "Mood improves 40%." "Research shows," with no study named.
- "Smell recall is 65% after a year." Probably a misreading of Engen & Ross 1973, an odor-recognition experiment (PhilArchive).
- "Rosemary boosts memory 75%." A newspaper decimal error; the reported improvement was about 7.5%, from a conference presentation (FactCrescendo).
- "63% less anxiety" (Memorial Sloan-Kettering). No primary source we could check.
- "Scent increases sales by 20%" with no source. The real studies near that figure are Herrmann 2013 (one simple scent in one Swiss store, section 5) and the 23% most-favorable case in the meta-analysis (section 1). Both come with conditions, so we quote them only with those conditions.
If you see one of these numbers on this site, it is a mistake; tell us and we will remove it.
.avif)